As I’ve said elsewhere, season six is a bit paradoxical. On its face, it’s even more middle-of-the-road than season four, with a whopping 14 three-star episodes (that’s more than half of the season!)—and yet, its two five-star episodes are absolutely phenomenal pieces of work that are among the very best the series ever produced. It is simultaneously a season that showcases the depth and sophistication that its writers have developed over the course of all the previous seasons, and the one in which the series begins to show its age.
"Realm of Fear" works reasonably well as a character story, but its plot is decidedly unsatisfactory. There are some good Barclay moments here, and watching this always-fun and always-relatable minor…
Season six's first real "hit" exhibits the usual strengths and weaknesses to be expected from a Ron Moore TNG episode: a fairly thin plot featuring somewhat underdeveloped sci-fi concepts, paired…
This is the third episode that I've rated with three stars so far this season, and each has been wildly different. The season premier was half-baked, frivolous fun; "Realm of…
"Rascals" is an episode with a beyond-absurd premise and an insultingly implausible plot, but one that somehow manages to be entertaining enough that I actually don't hate it. When you…
There aren't a lot of TNG episodes that aim almost exclusively for comedy; even "Rascals," the episode immediately before this one, has some non-comedic aspirations, despite its ridiculousness. But "A…
I've now given three-star ratings to a full two thirds of the nine sixth-season episodes that I've reviewed so far, culminating with this one. This wasn't the first time that…
Reversing the usual trend for TNG two-parters, "Chain of Command" gives us a part one that, whatever its merits, is definitively overshadowed by an absolute standout of a part two.…
This episode is widely regarded as one of TNG's most impressive, and rightly so. The scenes between Picard and his Cardassian torturer, Gul Madred, are disturbing, compelling, and complex, and…
This is a unique and fun episode that, while never as impactful on subsequent viewings, is a real mind-bender the first time you see it (or it was for me,…
Whatever it was that the writers were going for with "Aquiel," it seems to me that it didn't quite come together. The episode has assorted flaws, but the main one…
Just a few episodes after exchanging her old outfits for a standard Starfleet uniform, Counselor Troi is suddenly given an episode in which she plays an unprecedentedly serious and substantive…
"Tapestry" may be my personal pick for all-time favorite TNG episode. A philosophical exploration of how our pasts (including the parts of them that we're least proud of) shape us…
This is kind of an oddball of an episode. I usually remember it mainly as "the Data dreaming one," probably because that story thread is the one that interests me…
Without a doubt, "Birthright" is TNG's oddest two-part episode. Instead of one story split over two episodes because it was clearly too big to fit into a single one, it…
This is another of those relatively rare "fun, but not deep" TNG episodes—a description (not necessarily in those exact words) that I also applied to both "Power Play" (three stars)…
Sigh. I remember really liking this one years ago. I always had issues with its ending, but I fully expected to be charmed enough by the rest of it, even…
I can't give "The Chase" more than three stars, but I actually enjoyed it somewhat more than I expected to on the rewatch immediately preceding the writing of this review.…
Poor Commander Riker! Two and a half seasons after "Future Imperfect," he once again finds himself trapped in an illusory scenario that has him running around in reaction-mode for most…
This is a bad episode, and pretty much nothing about it works (or even particularly makes sense). There are, alas, worse episodes of TNG, and I even considered giving this…
You can't help but to admire the ambition of this episode, which plunges Worf into a crisis of faith, then immediately confronts him with an apparent miracle, and has him…
"Second Chances" is, in many ways, my kind of Trek. It starts with an awesomely out-there sci-fi premise (the transporter creates a duplicate of one of the main characters!), and…
"Timescape" is a pretty solid three-star offering about which I have a few minor quibbles but no major complaints, apart from some very general here's-why-I-don't-enjoy-it-more type observations. For the most…
And so, we come to TNG's fourth and final cliffhanger season finale. I'll be saving most of my my big-picture thoughts about "Descent" as a two-parter, and its place in…