Skip to content
Dave's New Duck

An Outlet for Various Writings and Other Projects

  • Home
  • Blog
  • TNG Reviews
  • Miscellaneous Creations

High-Concept Sci-Fi

One of 8 “‘story type” categories that I have identified (see “TNG Story Types” under “Miscellany”). Episodes that are primarily about (hopefully) cool sci-fi concepts and phenomena, or some kind of “weird shit going down,” fall into this category.

The Naked Now (⭑)

Posted by By FlyingPenguin July 27, 2020Posted inTNG Reviews: Season 1, ⭑Tags: High-Concept Sci-FiNo Comments
Everything about this episode is ill-conceived: ripping off the plot of an original series episode; doing so in the very first post-pilot episode of the new series; having all the…
Read More

Where No One Has Gone Before (⭑)

Posted by By FlyingPenguin July 27, 2020Posted inTNG Reviews: Season 1, ⭑Tags: High-Concept Sci-Fi, Personal/Cultural EncounterNo Comments
Though considerably better than the three previous episodes, this one is nevertheless still really bad.  It lacks the sort of fantastically ill-conceived premise that ruined all three of the post-pilot…
Read More

Lonely Among Us (⭑)

Posted by By FlyingPenguin July 27, 2020Posted inTNG Reviews: Season 1, ⭑Tags: Encounter with a Weird Alien, High-Concept Sci-Fi, Tech TroubleNo Comments
Despite suffering from some of the same fundamental problems as many of the other episodes of the season, this baby immediately strikes one as a very different sort of terrible…
Read More

Hide and Q (⭑)

Posted by By FlyingPenguin July 27, 2020Posted inTNG Reviews: Season 1, ⭑Tags: High-Concept Sci-FiNo Comments
This is hands-down the worst Q episode ever; much of Q's material here is so bad that not even John de Lanci can make watching it non-painful, and the premise…
Read More

11001001 (⭑⭑⭑)

Posted by By FlyingPenguin July 27, 2020Posted inTNG Reviews: Season 1, ⭑⭑⭑Tags: Enemy Encounter, High-Concept Sci-FiNo Comments
This is unquestionably the best episode of the first season—so much so that it’s actually hard to wrap one’s brain around its presence in the same season of the same…
Read More

We’ll Always Have Paris (⭑⭑)

Posted by By FlyingPenguin July 27, 2020Posted inTNG Reviews: Season 1, ⭑⭑Tags: High-Concept Sci-Fi, Personal/Cultural EncounterNo Comments
Way back in my early teens, when TNG was originally airing (and when its first-season episodes were about all I knew of the show), this one was one of my…
Read More

The Neutral Zone (⭑)

Posted by By FlyingPenguin July 27, 2020Posted inTNG Reviews: Season 1, ⭑Tags: High-Concept Sci-Fi, Political IntrigueNo Comments
This is another episode that (like "We’ll Always Have Paris") I remember quite liking as a 14-year-old, so it pains me a bit to slam it too harshly—but this one,…
Read More

Elementary, Dear Data (⭑⭑⭑)

Posted by By FlyingPenguin July 27, 2020Posted inTNG Reviews: Season 2, ⭑⭑⭑Tags: Enemy Encounter, High-Concept Sci-Fi, Outside the Trek Milieu1 Comment
This is one of the first genuinely good and flat-out enjoyable episodes of the series (notably, only the second one that I have rated above two stars).  Its main weakness…
Read More

The Schizoid Man (⭑)

Posted by By FlyingPenguin July 27, 2020Posted inTNG Reviews: Season 2, ⭑Tags: High-Concept Sci-Fi, Personal/Cultural EncounterNo Comments
The third of the four early-second-season Data-focused episodes, this one is, alas, a complete bomb.  Its few paltry redeeming features are these: 1. Dr. Selar, though the reason why she…
Read More

Unnatural Selection (⭑⭑)

Posted by By FlyingPenguin July 27, 2020Posted inTNG Reviews: Season 2, ⭑⭑Tags: High-Concept Sci-FiNo Comments
My main overall reaction to this episode is that it's a fundamentally forgettable one.  While not entirely without merits, it needed a lot of work before it could qualify as…
Read More

Time Squared (⭑⭑)

Posted by By FlyingPenguin July 27, 2020Posted inTNG Reviews: Season 2, ⭑⭑Tags: High-Concept Sci-FiNo Comments
This episode wants really badly to be a good one, and significant portions of it are really engaging.  It has an intriguing story idea, really great visual effects, and some…
Read More

Q Who (⭑⭑⭑⭑⭑)

Posted by By FlyingPenguin July 27, 2020Posted inTNG Reviews: Season 2, ⭑⭑⭑⭑⭑Tags: Enemy Encounter, High-Concept Sci-FiNo Comments
I said in my review of "Pen Pals" that most of the best and worst episodes of this season are clustered together in its final third. Nothing illustrates this better…
Read More

Evolution (⭑⭑⭑)

Posted by By FlyingPenguin July 27, 2020Posted inTNG Reviews: Season 3, ⭑⭑⭑Tags: Encounter with a Weird Alien, High-Concept Sci-Fi, Personal/Cultural Encounter1 Comment
With the start of season three, TNG finally attains its full maturity.  As with "The Child," I can't really discuss this episode without also offering some broader observations—this time about…
Read More

Deja Q (⭑⭑⭑⭑⭑)

Posted by By FlyingPenguin July 27, 2020Posted inTNG Reviews: Season 3, ⭑⭑⭑⭑⭑Tags: High-Concept Sci-Fi, Personal/Cultural Encounter1 Comment
This pure classic is unique among TNG's Q episodes in that it's the only one that's actually fundamentally about Q; rather than serving as a foil, a guide, or a…
Read More

Yesterday’s Enterprise (⭑⭑⭑⭑⭑)

Posted by By FlyingPenguin July 27, 2020Posted inTNG Reviews: Season 3, ⭑⭑⭑⭑⭑Tags: High-Concept Sci-Fi, Personal/Cultural Encounter1 Comment
What an absolutely fantastic episode this is! A true classic, beyond any doubt. I almost don't even know where to begin in talking about it. Despite the many cool ideas…
Read More

The Offspring (⭑⭑⭑)

Posted by By FlyingPenguin July 27, 2020Posted inTNG Reviews: Season 3, ⭑⭑⭑Tags: High-Concept Sci-Fi, Political Intrigue2 Comments
Argh. How does one rate an episode that entangles a delightful and moving story with an ill-conceived and irritating one? I so very, very much want to like this one.…
Read More

Transfigurations (⭑⭑)

Posted by By FlyingPenguin July 27, 2020Posted inTNG Reviews: Season 3, ⭑⭑Tags: High-Concept Sci-Fi, Personal/Cultural Encounter6 Comments
Unfortunately, the last "regular" episode of season three (prior to the grand finale) is a lackluster offering. "Transfigurations" combines a nonsensical sci-fi premise with a narrative structure reminiscent of some…
Read More

The Best of Both Words: Part II (⭑⭑⭑⭑⭑)

Posted by By FlyingPenguin July 27, 2020Posted inTNG Reviews: Season 4, ⭑⭑⭑⭑⭑Tags: Enemy Encounter, High-Concept Sci-Fi7 Comments
There is a conventional wisdom—not universally agreed upon, by any means, but certainly subscribed to by many fans—according to which this second half of TNG's epic two-part Borg extravaganza does…
Read More

Remember Me (⭑⭑⭑⭑)

Posted by By FlyingPenguin July 27, 2020Posted inTNG Reviews: Season 4, ⭑⭑⭑⭑Tags: High-Concept Sci-Fi1 Comment
This is a delightful episode that I have always really liked. It's also one of a depressingly tiny number of episodes with Dr. Crusher as the featured character, and it…
Read More

Future Imperfect (⭑⭑⭑)

Posted by By FlyingPenguin July 27, 2020Posted inTNG Reviews: Season 4, ⭑⭑⭑Tags: High-Concept Sci-Fi, Personal/Cultural Encounter1 Comment
This episode had great potential, and most of it is quite enjoyable, but its ending is a pretty big disappointment, and ultimately there's just not enough "meat" here to make…
Read More

The Loss (⭑⭑⭑)

Posted by By FlyingPenguin July 27, 2020Posted inTNG Reviews: Season 4, ⭑⭑⭑Tags: High-Concept Sci-Fi, Tech Trouble1 Comment
"The Loss" is a little-loved and admittedly fairly mediocre episode for which I nevertheless have always had a bit of a soft spot. It suffers both from Marina Sirtis's limitations…
Read More

Clues (⭑⭑⭑)

Posted by By FlyingPenguin July 27, 2020Posted inTNG Reviews: Season 4, ⭑⭑⭑Tags: Encounter with a Weird Alien, High-Concept Sci-Fi4 Comments
I don't especially like this episode, but I'm not sure that I can adequately justify my reaction to it. I also have a somewhat different relationship to this one than…
Read More

Night Terrors (⭑⭑⭑)

Posted by By FlyingPenguin July 27, 2020Posted inTNG Reviews: Season 4, ⭑⭑⭑Tags: High-Concept Sci-FiNo Comments
There are some really cool ideas at the heart of this episode, and parts of it have always worked for me, but there is also a lot of missed potential…
Read More

Identity Crisis (⭑⭑)

Posted by By FlyingPenguin July 27, 2020Posted inTNG Reviews: Season 4, ⭑⭑Tags: High-Concept Sci-Fi1 Comment
This episode has multiple flaws, but I've always felt that its #1 problem is simply that it is unbelievably boring. It's got a sci-fi premise about weird, basically invisible aliens…
Read More

The Host (⭑⭑)

Posted by By FlyingPenguin July 27, 2020Posted inTNG Reviews: Season 4, ⭑⭑Tags: High-Concept Sci-Fi, Personal/Cultural Encounter1 Comment
Season four has some great episodes, and I think of it as a good season of TNG overall, but there's no denying that its latter third contains a dismayingly long…
Read More

A Matter of Time (⭑⭑⭑)

Posted by By FlyingPenguin July 27, 2020Posted inTNG Reviews: Season 5, ⭑⭑⭑Tags: High-Concept Sci-Fi1 Comment
In a nutshell, "A Matter of Time" is an episode that I have always more or less liked but that I have never felt particularly strongly about. It's funny; three-star…
Read More

Conundrum (⭑⭑⭑)

Posted by By FlyingPenguin July 27, 2020Posted inTNG Reviews: Season 5, ⭑⭑⭑Tags: High-Concept Sci-Fi2 Comments
I enjoy this episode, and I remembered it fondly enough that I imagined possibly giving it four stars, but after re-watching, I can't justify that. Its plot doesn't hold up…
Read More

Power Play (⭑⭑⭑)

Posted by By FlyingPenguin July 27, 2020Posted inTNG Reviews: Season 5, ⭑⭑⭑Tags: High-Concept Sci-FiNo Comments
I find "Power Play" to be a surprisingly compelling episode given its limited ambitions and lack of anything that could be called "depth." It doesn't really try to be anything…
Read More

Cause and Effect (⭑⭑⭑⭑)

Posted by By FlyingPenguin July 27, 2020Posted inTNG Reviews: Season 5, ⭑⭑⭑⭑Tags: High-Concept Sci-Fi1 Comment
"Cause and Effect" is an undeniable TNG classic. It's always been one of the first episodes that come to mind when I reminisce in a general way about TNG in…
Read More

The Perfect Mate (⭑⭑⭑⭑)

Posted by By FlyingPenguin July 27, 2020Posted inTNG Reviews: Season 5, ⭑⭑⭑⭑Tags: High-Concept Sci-Fi, Personal/Cultural Encounter1 Comment
I have always loved this episode. My fondness for it has never blinded me to the problematic aspects of its premise, which do need to be factored into any overall…
Read More

Posts pagination

1 2 Next page

TNG Reviews

  • Season 1
  • Season 2
  • Season 3
  • Season 4
  • Season 5
  • Season 6
  • Season 7
  • Miscellany
Copyright 2025 — Dave M. Jacobi. All rights reserved. Sinatra WordPress Theme
Scroll to Top